Donor Retention Research: How Faith-Based Nonprofits in the Midwest Increased Recurring Giving
December 15, 2025
Faith-based nonprofits have to keep donor relationships personal while their outreach grows. A consortium of Midwest religious organizations came to Altruvia because their recurring donation rates were declining and their spreadsheets couldn't tell them why. They needed to hear from the donors themselves.
The Challenge: Understanding Donor Motivations
The metrics showed monthly giving falling but couldn't explain why. Exit surveys went unanswered and donor feedback was sparse. The organizations needed to understand what was actually driving donor decisions, from younger donors rethinking their giving habits to long-time supporters who no longer felt connected to the mission.
"I learned more in three days of watching donor interviews than I had in six months of looking at dashboards.
The Insights: What Faith-Based Donors Actually Want
- •
Transparency over transactions: Donors wanted to see exactly where their money went, told through stories of real impact.
- •
Community connection: Many lapsed donors cited feeling like 'just a number' rather than part of a faith community.
- •
Flexible giving options: Younger donors preferred giving small amounts frequently rather than large annual gifts.
- •
Mission alignment: Donors needed regular reminders of how their giving connected to their values and their faith.
The Results
The research wrapped in a few weeks and surfaced things no survey had. The consortium rebuilt its donor communication strategy around the findings. Recurring giving rose 47% within six months.
Ready to achieve similar results?
Get in touch to see how Altruvia can help your organization understand your donors and volunteers better.
Get in touch